Is it worth less than what you paid for it?
Saturday, August 20th, 2011
So much has been written about the housing market problem; who’s to blame, why’d it happen, on and on. What we haven’t seen much of is the fact that during the “bubble,” mtge lenders were allowing a buyer to have a 61% debt to income ratio. All their debts, added to the new mtge they were contemplating (mtge payment, interest, taxes and insurance), could be 61% of their gross income.
So, take a family of four, one spouse earning $15k and the other $45k, buying a home with a 61% ratio.
Total income is $60k, and with the new mtge, they have $36,600 of annual debt. Well, they still have $23,400 left, right? Oh no, the 61% is of gross income. If they were lucky enough to have to pay only 10% of the gross income for Fed and State taxes ($6,000), that still leaves them with $17,400, or $1,450 per month, for everything else they need.
Let’s help them budget? I mean, if the lender felt this approach was OK, who are we to question?
We need money for: utilities, trash service, hlth/life/auto insurance, food, clothes, school supplies, vacation and entertainment (?) and for emergencies.
Let’s use a conservative amount for all the insurance needed…say $650 per month, and use a utility number of $150 per month. OK, we’ve still got $650 left for the rest of our budget. Let ‘r snap, c’mon you financial guru’s out there, budget up now!
What you didn’t know is that the couple had a few grand in the bank, a little cushion, in case things got tight. They have this money because they were provided with a “nothing down” mtge. They were even allowed to roll the closing costs into the mtge. No skin in the game here…just monthly mtge payments.
How’s the budget coming? Did you have to pull out vacation and entertainment money? Is there enough left after that?
Let’s take this family out a few years and see how they’re doing. Whoops, the $15k earner lost their job. Monthly income is now only $1,087 vs the $1,450 they had three yrs ago. And geez, the savings are depleted as well.
So, the brain jobs that set this program up, the lenders, what did they do wrong? I mean, let’s just go with basic math, let’s not bother the Actuaries, let’s go back to 6th grade math and try it again.
Today, as in the years before the “bubble,” the ratio used is 31% of gross income. Whew, they’re on the right track now, ‘eh? What a joke! Unfortuneately, the joke is on “Joe the plumber.” The lenders received bail out money for the errors they made. Should they have?
All these homes, homes that have 100% mortgages on them, homes that the buyers can’t pay for, or, realize their home is worth less than it was in 2000, all these (26%) of all US homes, what does it all mean…where and when will it all shake out?
Do you wonder how the banks represent these underwater monuments on their balance sheets? Would their stock go right down the drain if they held them on their balance sheets at actual value?
I mean…if the bank holds a $600k mtge on a home that is now listed as a short sale, at $200k, is that what’s on the balance sheet? Or, is it still there at $600k? How about it bankers, send us the answer.
Well, there is some really good news to go with all this; if you can buy real estate now, you chance to be one of those people who can one day say: “I made my money in real estate!” The bargains are super! We’ve been putting our buyers into homes at huge savings. Just got a single mom into a T/H that sold for over $200k a few yrs ago, for $105k. A home that had $925k against it just sold for $510k. Another that has $4.5m against it, looks like it will get sold for $1.7m; the list goes on.
Today, as I write this post, in the four counties comprising the core Twin City area, there are 1,188 homes for sale for less than $100k, and 3,326 homes for sale in the $101k to $200k range. If you can buy now, do it! Rates are so low, we may not see anything like this again…ever. Buy now and you’ll have bragging rights in 7 to 10 years.
And, if you’re one of the unfortunate home owners who have to sell, give us a call so we can tell you how a “Short Sale,” may help you…or…how to sell and get your equity out.
Do you have an opinion or story to share? Please do, we love to hear from you even if your opinions differ from ours.
Ed





